Article (8)
Roles and Responsibilities of the Main Stakeholders in the Process of
Establishing Private Funds (Governance Mechanism)
1. The Federal Entity:
The Federal Entity that desires to establish Private Funds for developmental purposes,
such as advancing the sectors in which it operates or developing the target
groups/beneficiaries thereof, or otherwise.
Its role in the process of establishing Private Funds:
a. Preparing a strategic plan for the Fund, and aligning its functions with the objectives
of the plan and the related priorities.
b. Filling out the relevant form (approved by the General Secretariat of the Cabinet) and
submitting it to the Ministry, an accompanying memorandum confirming that the
Fund has fulfilled all the conditions and requirements specified in this Manual, with
and submitting all supporting documents.
2. The Ministry:
The Ministry shall be responsible for assessing the data provided by the Fund during its
establishment process, and conducting a review/evaluation of the request to ensure that
there are reasonable expectations regarding financial sustainability.
Its role in establishing Private Funds:
a. Receiving the requests for the establishment of Funds from the federal entities.
b. The Ministry shall evaluate the request on the basis of:
▪ The general financial sustainability of the Private Fund, and the compliance with
the financial policies and legislation applicable in the Federal Government.
▪ The governance mechanism and the operational model of the Private Fund.
c. Requesting the federal entity that submitted the request to provide missing or
additional data to complete the request procedures.
d. Submitting a recommendation to the General Budget Committee for guidance
regarding the request submitted for the establishment of the Private Fund.
-- 11 of 16 --
Cabinet Resolution of 2022 Regarding the Adoption of the Procedures Manual for the Establishment of Private
Funds in the Federal Government
12
3. General Budget Committee:
Shall review the requests submitted for the establishment of Private Funds and provide
guidance thereon, either by approving, requesting amendment, or rejecting the request.
4. The Cabinet:
The authority vested with the power to grant final approval for the establishment of
Private Funds.
5. A Comprehensive Procedural Diagram Outlining the Governance/Accountability
Pathways
6. Scoring Matrix for Financial Sustainability and Related Topics:
The development of a set of standardized scores for all requests for establishing Private
Funds will contribute to enhancing consistency and transparency in the evaluation
process, particularly regarding evaluations related to financial sustainability.
Areas of Focus Description Score Range (1 to 5)
Financial
Sustainability
▪ Financial Sustainability Plan developed
for the Private Fund.
▪ Operating and Capital Budget
Requirements (revenues and
expenditures) funding necessary to
perform the functions.
-- 12 of 16 --
Cabinet Resolution of 2022 Regarding the Adoption of the Procedures Manual for the Establishment of Private
Funds in the Federal Government
13
Explanation of the scoring mechanism for evaluating the requests for establishing
Private Funds:
▪ Expected cash flow.
Risks ▪ The main risks (description and
assessment) associated with the Fund.
▪ Risk management framework related to
the Fund
▪ The mechanisms adopted by the Fund to
address risks.
• The Supreme Authority for
Decision -
Recommendation and Adoption
The Cabinet
-- 13 of 16 --
Cabinet Resolution of 2022 Regarding the Adoption of the Procedures Manual for the Establishment of Private
Funds in the Federal Government
14
Review and Recommendation
a. Points are allocated for each axis based on the inputs (evidence such as documents or
otherwise) submitted by the Federal Entity.
b. The exact score (on a scale from "1" to "5") shall be determined based on the following:
▪ The extent to which the information provided is detailed, its quality, and its importance
to the axis being evaluated.
▪ Supporting documents (along with best practices and feasibility studies) that provide
further evidence.
Score Description
1 ▪ No question was answered and/or a very brief answer was provided to the
questions asked.
2 ▪ Some questions were answered with a brief explanation without providing
supporting data.
▪ No supporting documents were submitted.
• Submitting the recommendation for
final approval to the Cabinet.
• Review and Guidance
• Review fund establishment request
• Analysis and evaluation of financial
performance
• Continuous monitoring of financial
performance
• Submission to the Federal General
Budget Committee
• Program supervision and coordination
with partners
• Responsible for submitting all the
required documents
Federal Entity (Sponsoring the Fund)
Coordination and Follow-up Unit (Ministry of Finance)
Fund
Coordination and
Follow-up Unit
(Ministry of Finance)
Federal General
Budget Committee
• Follow up on the implementation of
the Federal General Budget Committee’s
recommendation.
• Submitting the Final recommendation
to the Cabinet.
-- 14 of 16 --
Cabinet Resolution of 2022 Regarding the Adoption of the Procedures Manual for the Establishment of Private
Funds in the Federal Government
15
3 ▪ Some questions were answered with a brief explanation and partial data.
▪ A limited number of supporting documents were submitted.
4 ▪ All questions were answered with a complete explanation and supporting
data.
▪ Strong supporting documents were provided.
5 ▪ All questions were answered with detailed analysis (relevant) and
explanation/justifications/and complete data.
▪ Supporting documents covering every aspect of the evaluation criteria were
provided, including the external experts' evaluation (if necessary).
If the Fund fails to achieve a score of 4 or higher the average in each of the axes (as shown
above), the Ministry shall communicate with the concerned federal entity to request further
details and information so that the re-evaluation process achieves the minimum scores
required.
7. Detailed Evaluation Checklist:
The following checklist aims to assist the Ministry in reviewing the Fund in areas and
dimensions that fall under the main areas identified below. Such a list is also relevant to the
various federal entities requesting the establishment of Private Funds, as it specifies the type
of information required and the level of detail needed.
Axes of Focus Questions Requiring Answers
Details about the Sponsoring
Entity of the Private Fund and
confirmation of its support
▪ Who are the main stakeholders involved with the
Fund? Do they provide the necessary support?
Vision and Main Function ▪ What are the vision and strategic and
developmental objectives the Fund seeks to
achieve in the long term?
-- 15 of 16 --
Cabinet Resolution of 2022 Regarding the Adoption of the Procedures Manual for the Establishment of Private
Funds in the Federal Government
16
Axes of Focus Questions Requiring Answers
▪ Is the Fund closely aligned with the general
national objectives/priorities?
▪ How does the fund achieve a strong economic and
social impact on the target group?
▪ What is the Fund's scope of work? (Definition of
"scope": the relevant target group and the specific
financing tools used in carrying out the main
function of the Private Fund).
Fund's Strategy and Operational
Model
▪ Partners and target group.
▪ What helps the Fund and its concerned
stakeholders to achieve its objectives?
▪ What form will the operational model of the
Private Fund take?
Governance ▪ What is the Fund's internal and external
governance structure?
▪ What are the Fund's structures responsible for
communication, report preparation and
submission to the Fund’s management?
▪ Have the operational controls been defined?
Infrastructure and capabilities
(internal operations) supporting
the Private Fund
▪ What are the available infrastructure capabilities
and capacities to operate and manage the Fund?
Environmental and social
responsibility
▪ Does the Fund take into account the
environmental, social and strategic costs?
The Fund and the market's
overall landscape
▪ Are there other Private Funds with the same main
function or scope of work?
-- 16 of 16 --