Skip to main content

Ask a Lawyer·Labour / Employment

Labour / EmploymentAnswered

My employer responded to my labour case with a counterclaim against me

Asked by Anonymous·Jun 10, 2026·1 answers
Filed for unpaid salary and gratuity, and the company hit back with a counterclaim saying I damaged equipment and owe them training costs. None of this was ever mentioned before I went to court. Is this a common pressure tactic, and does their claim get decided in the same case as mine?

This answer is AI-generated by LEXAI. It is general legal information, not legal advice — verify anything you act on with a licensed UAE lawyer. How LEXAI uses AI

1 answers

Best answer
L
LEXAI

AI-generated answer

Jun 11, 2026
Yes, this is a familiar pressure tactic, and yes, the counterclaim is normally heard in the same case as your claim — the court deals with both and offsets any amounts it actually awards. But do not let the tactic work: a counterclaim is only as strong as its evidence, and the burden sits on the employer. For alleged equipment damage, they must prove the damage happened, that you caused it, and what it genuinely cost — not just assert it. For training costs, recovery generally requires a prior written agreement in which you undertook to repay defined training expenses in defined circumstances; a figure invented after you sued, never mentioned during your employment or in your final settlement discussions, tends to impress judges very little. The timing itself is your friend: point out that no damage report, deduction, or training-cost demand existed before you filed for your salary and gratuity. Respond formally to the counterclaim rather than ignoring it — submit a written reply with your contract, any handover or asset-return records, and the absence of any signed training-cost undertaking. Your own claim continues in parallel and is not suspended by theirs. An employment lawyer can prepare the defence to the counterclaim alongside pressing your original claim.
Helpful (0)

Facing something similar?

Describe your own situation below. Your details go to our team, and a suitable lawyer in the LEXAI directory may receive them so they can contact you about it.

Pick your situation so your enquiry can reach a suitable lawyer in the LEXAI directory who works in that area.

Your details stay private and are used only to handle your enquiry. Your enquiry may be offered to a suitable lawyer automatically, and may be offered to another if there is no response, so a lawyer can contact you about it. Privacy policy

Related Questions

Underlying law

Keep reading

Labour Employment

Labour Court Dubai in 2026: Filing, Conciliation, Fees and Timelines Explained

How the labour court Dubai system handles wage, termination and end-of-service claims in 2026 — from MoHRE complaint to judgment, including DIFC tribunal differences.

8 min read

Labour Employment

Sharjah Labour Court 2026: Federal Court Filing, MoHRE Conciliation and Appeals

How the Sharjah labour court works in 2026 — MoHRE conciliation, filing at the Federal Court of First Instance, Arabic-language rules, expedited tracks, appeals to Sharjah and cassation in Abu Dhabi.

9 min read

Labour Employment

DEWS in the DIFC: How the Employee Workplace Savings Plan Works

Your DIFC employer must pay at least 5.83% of your monthly basic wage into DEWS or another certified scheme every month, rising to 8.33% after five years. Who is covered, how the 50% floor works, what UAE and GCC nationals are owed, and how to get the money out.

5 min read